The languor of idleness is worse than the worst weariness of toil – Hugh Black
I was thinking recently about how so many people have recently had to re-think their retirement plans as their nest eggs have been depleted or vanished altogether due to our economic meltdown. People who were thinking that they would be quitting the 9-5 are now thinking about working for the forseeable future – they can’t afford not to work.
All of this got me thinking about a question that I’ve often wondered about: Will I ever fully retire to the point I’m not working at all any more? If I could retire early, would I want to?
Working Into Old Age?
We have a close family friend that is a pastor, and he’s still working at 101 years old. He doesn’t seem his age, and part of the reason I think is because he is still active and working. He has always said that he would never retire because working makes him happy, and he wants to remain busy and actively challenging himself. He still preaches from time to time, is active at his senior living center. In fact he just finished writing another (one of many) book! Not bad for someone who is over a century old, and he’s about the happiest person I know. (One of his books is titled “Something Funny Happened On The Way To Retirement. I Never Arrived“)
Why is he so happy? I think he’s happy because his work means so much to him, and helps give him meaning. Some other reasons to continue working:
Work provides a sense of social connection, structure for daily living, intellectual challenge and indeed, meaning – more so than our leisure activities, argues Darren Wickham, an actuary at Mercer Human Resource Consulting.
Work gives us structure, challenge and social connection. All good things that people often don’t think about or even realize. Things we won’t miss until its gone. The article goes on to discuss this:
Only when we retire do we discover what we’ve lost, says Christopher Sharpley, Adjunct Professor of Psychology at the University of New England. He says that retirees commonly experience depression after giving up work.
“Immediately after retirement there’s a strong upsurge in wellbeing for the first six or so months, which is commonly known as the ‘honeymoon’ period,” he says. “Then after one or two years, there’s a decrease in wellbeing, which can often turn into quite serious depression.”
A study done by the University of Chicago found some other interesting things:
A hundred men and women of various ages and occupations wore an electronic pager for a week. They were beeped eight times a day at random and asked to fill out a booklet, giving details about what they were doing when they beeped and how they felt. When at work, about 54 per cent reported feeling ‘strong, creative, motivated, active and positive’. But away from work, only 18 per cent reported experiencing these sensations. While working, 16 per cent reported feeling ‘dull, weak and dissatisfied’, whilst outside of work, 52 per cent reported experiencing these sensations. But at work, when asked what they would rather be doing, most said they would rather not be at work but engaged in leisure activities.
Why the paradox? Because when it comes to work, we don’t heed the evidence of our senses; we believe the prevailing cultural stereotype that work is bad, an imposition to be avoided. When we’re at leisure we’re free to choose, so we think we ought to be happier.
So work, while it can be hard, frustrating and even stressful, also has a lot of positive side effects including being a good social outlet, challenging our reasoning and giving us meaning.
Retirement Isn’t For Me
For me, I don’t ever plan to fully retire. The most I plan on doing is having a transition from working 8-10 hour days to working a little less than that. I don’t ever want to stop working completely. If I did, I know I would get depressed, bored and unhappy.
Human beings are happiest when they’re rising to meet a challenge; the reward is the sense of satisfaction and achievement in overcoming it. That’s what work provides. If we don’t have that, we become depressed.
When counselling groups of men, Sharpley’s advice is, don’t retire.
“Think of yourself as undergoing a transition to a new form of work, something challenging and engaging, whether it’s a recreational activity, voluntary work, or starting a small business. Those who see it as a transition to a new form of work do best,” he says.
I’ll end this with a quote from Proverbs 12:14:
A man will be satisfied with good by the fruit of his words, And the deeds of a man’s hands will return to him.
Hard work is worth your while, and the deeds of your hand will return to you! Keep on working!
How about you? Do you ever plan to fully retire, or do you think you’ll keep working as long as you can? Do you think work makes you happy? (as weird as that sounds)
The Happy Rock says
Nope not me. Getting out of debt was the first step towards working a job that fills my soul and compliments me. Once that happens, I will hope I never retire!
The Happy Rocks last blog post..Crafty Creditors Are Making Changes
Frugal Dad says
Put it this way…I don’t plan to ever retire, but I do aspire to one day not have to work for money. There are plenty of other things I would rather do with my time than update lines of code from a cubicle for eight hours a day. Sorry, I know that sounded like a line from Office Space, but it pretty much sums up my feelings. Nice, thought-provoking post.
Frugal Dads last blog post..Emergency Funds On Steroids
Peter says
Good point. I plan to work as long as i can, but at the same time I don’t want to HAVE to work.
Justin "The Night Trader" says
Yep, I’m with you (I even have the Office Space Kit ;-) ). I love working with technology, but 8-10hrs/day in my cube drives me nuts! First I’d like to move to working a job that allows me to be out and about a little more, and then at some point become financially independent and be able to work for free :-). I’ve got enough ministry ideas to keep me busy long past the time I’m dead and gone.
Craig says
@Peter I think you have the mentality of most people. Work for as long as you can, but because you want to, not because you have to. In these days people have to work longer because it’s too expensive to live. I don’t see that changing ever, so more people will have to work later.
Patrick says
I think I will always be working on something. I’m not the type to sit around without a project of some sort. I don’t think I will be sitting in an office though. I think it will be something entrepreneurial or creative. That’s just how my mind functions. :)
Patricks last blog post..Welcome to the White House President Obama, Here’s a List of Things to Do
Squawkfox says
Cool question. Nope. I’ll always play at some sorta work, but hopefully on my terms. :)
Squawkfoxs last blog post..Free Printable Workout Log
Marc says
I think Benjamin Franklin had the right idea. After his printing business had provided enough cash flow that he could “retire” he became an inventor and a statesman. He got to seek out his purpose in life.
Peter Anderson says
That sounds like a great way to go about it. Work hard on things to earn cash flow so you can work on things you love.